Do you know that feeling when you’re deep in the middle of a makeup declutter, and you stumble across a product you completely forgot about—only to fall head-over-heels in love with it all over again? It’s like finding treasure in your own home. You start asking yourself, “Why did I ever stop using this?!” Or worse—“Wait… did I ever use this at all?”
This exact thing happened to me recently when I was casually decluttering a few blushes and palettes. What was supposed to be a short organizing session turned into a full-on makeup rediscovery moment. I started swatching, reminiscing, and rotating products into my current routine that had been buried for far too long. The best part? It felt like I went shopping—without spending a dime.
So today, I’m sharing five forgotten favorites from my stash that I’m now obsessed with all over again. These gems are back in rotation, giving me all the feels and reminding me that sometimes, the best beauty finds are already in your own collection.
⸻
1. Milani Rose Powder Blush in “Coral Cove”
If springtime was a blush, this would be it.
When I rediscovered this, I was in awe. This bold yet wearable coral shade makes my skin look fresh, warm, and alive. The formula still glides on like a dream—no patchiness, no fuss. Just smooth, blendable pigment that warms up my complexion beautifully. I honestly can’t believe I let this one get lost in the shuffle.
Why did I stop wearing it? Honestly… it just got lost in the sea of new blushes I kept buying. You know how it is—new launches, limited edition packaging, and suddenly your tried-and-true staples are pushed to the back of the drawer.
But Coral Cove is officially back in my spring makeup wardrobe and earning its spot all over again. If you have this in your stash—dust it off and show it some love. It deserves it.
⸻
2. Laura Mercier Translucent Loose Setting Powder in “Medium Deep”
This powder needs no introduction, but it sure deserved a re-entry into my routine.
I remember when this launched, and how excited I was to finally have a version that matched deeper skin tones. I’d been using the original translucent version for years, but Medium Deep felt like the perfect everyday finishing touch that didn’t leave me looking ashy or flat.
I pulled this out recently to pair with some of my stick foundations—and wow. The way it sets everything in place without dulling the radiance of my skin? Perfection. It blurs, mattifies just enough, and keeps my makeup fresh all day.
I’m honestly embarrassed that I ever let this sit untouched. Laura, girl, I’m sorry. We’re good again.
⸻
3. Pat McGrath Mothership II “Sublime” Eyeshadow Palette
Let me tell you: this palette has me in a chokehold… again!
I was binge-watching some older beauty YouTube videos—nostalgic hauls, reviews of classic palettes, you know the vibe—and the moment I saw someone swatching this beauty, I knew it was time to bring it out of storage. I immediately pulled it out of the box and put it front and center in my rotation tray.
And listen—every single time I use it, I fall in love again. The textures, the pigmentation, the blendability… it’s giving luxury, it’s giving drama, and it’s giving you should’ve never put me away, sis. Whether I’m going full glam or just doing a quick swipe of shimmer across the lids, this palette performs every time.
If you own any of the Pat McGrath Motherships and haven’t used them in a while—consider this your reminder. She’s still that girl.
⸻
4. Shayla x Dose of Colors “Happily Ever After” Blush & Glow Face Palette
This poor palette has been through it—cracked packaging, a few near-death drops—but it still hits every single time.
I’ve had this limited edition beauty in my spring rotation for a few years now. But this season, I pulled it back out to match with a dress that needed that perfect warm blush and glow combo… and it delivered. Again.
Despite its broken state, the product inside is still vibrant, smooth, and blendable. The blush gives me just the right amount of flush, and the highlighter? Whew. That glow is still everything. And I also use this as an eyeshadow palette!
Limited edition or not, this is a staple in my collection. It’s the makeup equivalent of that comfy pair of shoes that go with everything—reliable, flattering, and full of memories.
⸻
5. MAC x Proenza Schouler Blush Ombre in “Sunset Beach”
I’m not going to lie—I bought this strictly for the packaging. It was shiny, colorful, and limited edition. Classic make-up junkie behavior.
I didn’t even swatch it when I got home. It went into a box… and stayed there. Until recently.
During a blush cleanout, I came across this and decided to finally give it a try. And when I did? Instant regret for not using it sooner. The pink ombré gradient creates a custom blush look depending on how I swirl my brush. It’s soft, buildable, and gives a romantic flush, a pop of color and everything between, that’s surprisingly modern for a product released years ago.
Even better? It reminded me of a trending blush (won’t list the name), I had planned to grab during the Sephora sale—but now I don’t need to. I already have something better in my stash.
⸻
A Final Thought: Shop Your Stash, Sis
Falling back in love with your own collection is such a powerful thing. It feels nostalgic, empowering, and satisfying all at once. And if you’re a beauty enthusiast or collector like me, it can also help curb the constant desire to chase new releases.
There’s just something about rediscovering products that used to spark joy—or never got the chance to. Whether it’s a blush you bought for the packaging, a setting powder you swore by but stopped using, or a luxury palette that got lost in the hype of new launches—there’s so much untapped beauty just waiting in our drawers.
Next time you feel the urge to shop, do yourself a favor: take 10 minutes to go through one drawer. Swatch a few products. Test out an old fave. You may just find your next holy grail hiding in plain sight.
Let me know in the comments or tag me on Instagram (@misaglow) or (@misaglow_) on TikTok with your favorite rediscovered products. I’d love to see what’s made its way back into your rotation!
⸻
Ready to fall in love with your stash again?
Try decluttering by category (blush, lipstick, foundation), rotate your top five products into your vanity tray each week, and don’t be afraid to use the “fancy stuff.” You deserve to enjoy what you already own.
And remember: sometimes the best makeup is the makeup you already have.
